Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) Effect on Honey Bee Pathogens

University Research Review

ABSTRACT – 5 JANUARY 2020 – CHINA AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY

Honeybee gut microbiota plays an important role in host physiology and metabolism. Recent studies have shown that the influence of the resident microorganisms in the regulation of honeybee immune system is profound, which protects against the pathogen Serratia marcescens. However, only few of the core gut members in the regulation of immune functions have been studied. Here, we explored how different bee gut bacterial species aided in the clearance of the pathogenic Hafnia alvei, which causes bee septicemia with a high mortality rate. We found that both Gilliamella apicola W8136 and Lactobacillus apis W8172 protect honeybees from the opportunistic pathogen, while two other strains from Gilliamella and Lactobacillus did not affect the invasion of H. alvei. Transcriptomic analysis revealed that gut species induced different expression profiles in the gut. Specifically, two regulator genes from the Toll pathway, PGRP-S3 recognizing Gram-positive and Spätzle that bind to the Toll protein for the downstream signal transduction, were elevated by L. apis. Correspondingly, multiple genes encoding antibacterial proteins were also stimulated by L. apis. Interestingly, we found an increased expression of apidaecin, which also exhibited a high in vitro inhibitory effect on H. alvei. To elucidate the difference of strains in the host’s immune regulation, comparative genomic analyses indicate that the S-layer proteins unique to L. apis are potentially involved in honeybee Toll signaling and the activation of antibacterial protein production.

IMPORTANCE Honeybees are essential pollinators supporting global agricultural economies and food supplies. Recent honeybee decline has been linked to several factors, while pathogen infection is considered one of the most significant contributing factors. Although a limited number of bacterial pathogens have been identified, Hafnia alvei is one of the pathogens causing septicemia in adult bees. In this study, we showed that two bee gut members, Gilliamella and Lactobacillus, can clear H. alvei from invasion. Mono-colonization of specific strains can stimulate the host Toll signaling pathway and the downstream expression of AMPs. Specifically, apidaecin upregulated by the gut symbionts is more effective against the pathogen. Moreover, our genomic analysis suggests that the surface-layer proteins specific to Lactobacillus strains are an important driver of Toll signaling, highlighting the variation of bee gut strains in regulating the host immune system.

ABSTRACT – 11 OCTOBER 2023 – INTERNATIONAL CENTRE OF INSECT PHYSIOLOGY AND ECOLOGY, KENYA

The honey bee, Apis mellifera, is the most critical managed agricultural pollinator and its recent colony losses is of global concern. Bacterial pathogens are one of the causes attributed to the decline of the bee population. Serratia marcescens is an opportunistic pathogen with a broad host range, capable of affecting various plants and animals. S. marcescens can invade various tissues of the honey bee, including the gut and hemolymph, leading to severe infections and compromising bee health. S. marcescens is often associated with secondary infections, and can rapidly multiply forming biofilms, making it particularly challenging to control and eliminate. Understanding the interactions between S. marcescens and the honey bee, as well as exploring potential solutions such as probiotics, is crucial for bee health improvement. In this study, we assessed the effect of Lactobacillus kunkeei, a bee gut associated bacterium on honey bee survival, protection against the opportunistic pathogen S. marcescens, and activation of bee immune responses. Newly emerged worker bees were divided into groups: MD- no treatment, GH-inoculated with hive bees’ gut homogenate and Lk- inoculated with L. kunkeei. After five days of inoculation, bees in each respective group were exposed to the opportunistic pathogen S. marcescens. Our results show that L. kunkeei increased bee survival after S. marcescens infection, inhibited its proliferation in the gut, and reduced antimicrobial peptide genes expression in the gut epithelium compared to microbe-deprived bees in a laboratory setting. Our findings highlight the potential use of the probiotic to enhance bee health.

FUNDING This research was funded by the Newton-Utafiti grant from the British Council (grant 275898413), the Swiss National Science Foundation Postdoc Mobility (grants P300PA_174329 and P2ELP3_165168) and icipe core funding provided by UK Aid from the UK Government, Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida), Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (SDC), Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, and the Government of Kenya. The views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the donors.


A 2022 Review Publication Of Many Other Recent LAB and Bee Immunity Reseach

In this review, recent scientific advances on the use of LABs as microbial supplements in the diet of honey bees are summarized and discussed.

 Lactic acid bacteria are normal inhabitants of the gastrointestinal tract of many insects, and their presence in the honey bee intestinal tract has been consistently reported in the literature.

In the first section of this review, recent scientific advances in the use of LABs as probiotic supplements in the diet of honey bees are summarized and discussed.

The second section discusses some of the mechanisms by which LABs carry out their antimicrobial activity against pathogens.


Swift Grow Organic Fertiliser Logo

How Swift Grow Protects Bees and Restores Bee Population

INTRODUCTION

Above university publications (attached) show Lactobacillus bacteria is vital for promoting and sustaining bee health. As per Swift Grow laboratory analysis report showing a super concentration of 41% active ‘Lactic Acid Bacteria’ (LAB) as a percentage of the total active bacteria. Nursery testimonial and hundreds of anecdotal customer Google reviews report an increased bee activity since switching from chemical fertilizers to using Swift Grow. This corroborates with the natural association of bees to LAB rich flowers and the university findings. 

CHINA AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY

This university research paper explored how different bee gut bacterial species aided in the clearance of the pathogenic Hafnia alvei, which causes bee septicemia with a high mortality rate, and found that both Gilliamella apicola  and Lactobacillus apis  protect honeybees from the opportunistic pathogen. 

INTERNATIONAL CENTRE OF INSECT PHYSIOLOGY AND ECOLOGY

The ICIPE research assessed the effect of Lactobacillus kunkeei, a bee gut associated bacterium on honey bee survival, protection against the opportunistic pathogen S. marcescens, and activation of bee immune responses. Their results show that L. kunkeei increased bee survival after S. marcescens infection, inhibited its proliferation in the gut, and reduced antimicrobial peptide genes expression in the gut epithelium compared to microbe-deprived bees in a laboratory setting.

SWIFT GROW CORRELATION

These research papers have a direct correlation to the high concentration of LAB found in liquid Swift Grow fertiliser (as per the Swift Grow laboratory test report) wherein the fertilised plants convert it to the floral LAB that the bees are attracted to and take to their hive for their hive and larvae to stay healthy.  

OBSERVED EVIDENCE

Various Swift Grow testimonial from a local nurseries and dosens of home gardeners testimonials using Swift Grow have reported an increased activity of bees on their flowers once they started using Swift Grow. This observation corroberates with hundreds of other customers anecdotal feedback and links back to the university verification that bees naturally associate with and are attracted to floral LAB found in flowers fertilised by Swift Grow which is rich in LAB. 

CAUSAL ANALYSIS

Intensive modern farming practices deplete the soil of its natural balance of soil microbiota, including LAB, which bees depend on their floral LAB form. Lactobacillus-depleted flowers collateral damage are bees’ inability to fight off pathogen. Conversely, plants that have access to sufficient levels of LAB in their soil produce flowers that are rich in the floral form of Lactobacillus which bees are naturally attracted to. 

SUMMARY

As the two university publications verify, LAB has a direct correlation on bee health and their ability to fight off pathogens that have of recent times decimated bee population in certain parts of the world including North America that heavily uses chemical fertilisers. 

GOOD NEWS FOR BEE KEEPERS

Bee keepers around Australia and the world should know about the abundant amount of LAB found in Swift Grow that will benefit their bee population and the wider ecosystem! Bee keeper associations should champion the usage of Swift Grow fertiliser to commercial farmers and local governments in order to promote bee health which has a direct effect on the rest of the farming economy.

SWIFT GROW

Swift Grow, developed in 2017, is the only full spectrum soil microbiota biostimulant on the market that is super-rich in LAB and ticks all the environmentally friendly boxes whilst being safe for humans and animals. Swift Grow is an organic powerhouse of nutrition for soil, restores depleted soil, does not burn plants and is naturally friendly to the waterways and oceans. On top of all that it is odourless and comes in concentrated liquid form for ease of transport and viable to use from backyard garden to commercial size farms.

SWIFT LIFE

Swift Life, developed in 2023, is a world-first 100% LAB.


Positive Implications on Human Health and our Environment

An increase in the bee population can have a number of positive effects on the environment.

Bees are important pollinators and this process helps to ensure the reproduction and survival of many species of plants, including those that provide food for people and other animals.

Promotes Well-Being!

Swift Grow promotes Well-Being!
Yes, we have reports from all over Australis that the improvement in the soil and plant quality is also improving the situation for local bees.

Increased Bee Population

Swift Grow is restoring bee population all over Australia (and the world wherever Swift Grow is used!). And the increased bee population has all the beneficial knock-on effects to overall garden heath.

Attracts Bees

Swift Grow and Swift Fort attract all bees including the
‘Blue Banded Bee’ that is native to Australia.
(This Type of Bee was once endangered until Swift Grow users are now reporting seeing them again in their gardens.)

Improved Bee Immunity

Swift Grow assists and improves Bee’s Immunity to pathogens! While bees are generally hardy creatures, they can become vulnerable when their immune system is compromised. Swift Grow and Swift Fort restores bee immunity and their health by restoring the floral Lactobacillus bacteria found in the flower pollens that bees collect and return to their hive to feed their baby bees.